Blog

Benchmarking incumbent services through indicative service assessments

As part of a recent Discovery project, we used our research findings to carry out an indicative service assessment of an incumbent service. 

Typically, service assessments are an important part of the assurance process for digital services, occurring for the first time at the end of an Alpha phase. Our Discovery recommendations are always mindful of this and reflect how teams can progress their services in a way that meets the standards required of them. 

In this instance, we decided to map our Discovery research findings about an incumbent service against the service standard as a benchmark for the service team to understand the gap that would need to be bridged to satisfy assurance processes for a future service.  

This proved to be a helpful lens to evaluate and critique the incumbent service, evidenced by user research, whilst stepping back from the entrenched cultural norms of the organisation. This was particularly useful as the current system had been in use across the organisation for several years. 

The insights from this process enabled us to make recommendations for Alpha, whilst acknowledging where the effort may be needed to align best practices with the evolving needs of users for the future service. 

Going forward, we will continue to use the lens of an indicative service assessment to assess incumbent services to support the case for change, where it is needed to improve the service. 


Related Case Studies

A critique of the leaver survey approach for HIT Training

HIT Training Ltd (HIT) is the leading specialist training and apprenticeship provider for the UK’s hospitality, catering and retail…

Discovery for NHS England’s national postgraduate trainee recruitment system

NHS England is responsible for the national postgraduate trainee recruitment system (Oriel), which is used to recruit postgraduate trainees.  The…

More from the Author

Service designer

John Gribbin 22/03/2024

The importance of defining problems

We recently had to think very hard about how to…

John Gribbin 08/03/2024

Benchmarking incumbent services through indicative service assessments

As part of a recent Discovery project, we used our research findings to carry out an indicative service assessment of an incumbent service. 

John Gribbin 29/09/2023

Can ChatGPT help to articulate user needs?

We have recently been thinking about the way in which…